Jamaican Curry Goat
Jamaica's Sunday favourite: bone-in goat marinated in curry, allspice and thyme, slowly simmered with a whole scotch bonnet and potatoes into a rich golden gravy.
Method
Rinse the goat pieces (bone-in, about 4 cm), pat them dry and check for small bone splinters. Put them in a bowl with most of the curry powder, the allspice, salt, black pepper, half the onion, half the garlic, the grated ginger, and half the scallions and thyme. Rub everything in with your hands (wear gloves; curry stains), cover and refrigerate for at least , ideally overnight.
Add in this stepGoat, bone-in, cut into 4 cm pieces 500 gJamaican curry powder 1½ tbspGround allspice (pimento) ½ tspSalt 1 tspGround black pepper ½ tspOnion, sliced ½Garlic cloves, crushed 2Fresh ginger, grated 10 gScallions, chopped 1Fresh thyme sprigs 1½
Heat the oil in a heavy 22 cm pot over medium heat. Add the remaining curry powder and stir for until it darkens slightly and smells toasty. Jamaican cooks call this 'burning' the curry, but stop before it turns black or it will taste bitter.
Add in this stepVegetable oil 1½ tbspJamaican curry powder 1 tbsp
medium heatTurn the heat up to medium-high heat. Shake the marinade vegetables off the meat and set them aside, then add the goat and turn it in the curry oil for , until every side is coated and lightly browned. Stir the vegetables back in for the last minute.
medium-high heatPour in most of the water, so the meat is almost covered, and add the rest of the onion, garlic, scallions and thyme. Drop in the whole scotch bonnet without cutting or piercing it. Bring to a boil on high heat, then cover, turn down to low heat and simmer for . Stir every 20 minutes and add a splash of hot water if the pot looks dry.
Add in this stepWater 480 mlOnion, sliced ½Garlic cloves, crushed 2Scallions, chopped 1Fresh thyme sprigs 1½Scotch bonnet pepper, whole 1
high heat→low heatPeel the potatoes, cut them into 3 cm chunks and add them with the remaining water. Simmer uncovered on medium-low heat for , stirring now and then, until the meat pulls easily off the bone and some of the potato breaks down to thicken the gravy. If the pepper starts to split, lift it out straight away.
Add in this stepPotatoes 300 gWater 120 ml
medium-low heatTurn off the heat. Carefully lift out the scotch bonnet and the bare thyme stems, taste the gravy and add a little salt if needed. Let it rest for , then serve with rice and peas, plain white rice or roti.
Cook's tip
Bone-in meat gives the richest gravy; ask the butcher to chop shoulder or leg into 4 cm pieces. Lamb shoulder or mutton works the same way (lamb needs 15–20 minutes less). For more heat, prick the scotch bonnet once with a knife in step 5; for a mild pot, take it out after 30 minutes.
Cooking it at camp
Marinate at home and carry the meat in a sealed bag in a well-iced cooler. Use a heavy Dutch oven on a gas burner or over steady coals with the lid on, and check the liquid more often, because outdoor heat is uneven. A pressure cooker cuts the simmering to about 35 minutes.