Rookie Pan
← All recipes
Pakistan, Asia

Nihari

Pakistan's slow-cooked beef stew: bone-in shank simmered for hours with warm spices until it melts into a thick, silky, gently fiery gravy.

ServingsServes 2
Total cooking time3 h 35 min
DifficultyMedium

Method

  1. Pat the beef dry and cut it, bone and all, into 5 cm pieces (a butcher will happily do this). Slice the onion thinly and grate the garlic and ginger to a fine paste. For the garnish, cut the ginger into fine matchsticks, slice the chillies, chop the coriander and cut the lemon into wedges.

  2. Melt the ghee in a heavy 22 cm pot over medium heat and fry the onion for , stirring often, until deep golden at the edges. Don't let it blacken or the gravy turns bitter.

    Add in this stepGhee or vegetable oil 3 tbspOnion (medium) 1

    medium heat
  3. Turn the heat up to medium-high heat, add the beef and the garlic-ginger paste and cook for , until the meat has lost its raw red colour and the sharp garlic smell turns nutty.

    Add in this stepBone-in beef shank 500 gGarlic cloves 5Fresh ginger, grated 15 g

    medium-high heat
  4. Lower the heat to medium-low heat and add the Kashmiri chilli, turmeric, ground fennel, ground ginger, garam masala and salt with 2 to 3 tbsp of water. Stir constantly for so the spices don't scorch; move on when red-tinged oil starts seeping out at the edges.

    Add in this stepKashmiri chilli powder 1½ tspGround turmeric ½ tspGround fennel seeds 1 tspGround ginger ½ tspGaram masala 0.6 tspSalt 1¼ tsp

    medium-low heat
  5. Pour in the water, bring to a rolling boil over high heat for and skim off the foam. Cover, turn down to low heat and simmer for , stirring every 30 minutes and topping up with a little hot water if the liquid drops below the meat. It is ready when the meat shreds easily with a fork and comes away from the bone.

    Add in this stepWater 1,200 ml

    high heat→low heat
  6. Whisk the flour into the cold water until completely smooth. Stirring the pot, pour the slurry in a thin stream, add the rest of the garam masala and simmer over low heat for , stirring often because it catches easily. When the gravy coats the back of a spoon and no longer tastes of raw flour, check the salt.

    Add in this stepWholewheat flour (atta) or plain flour 2½ tbspCold water (for the flour) 100 mlGaram masala 0.4 tsp

    low heat
  7. Warm the remaining ghee in a small pan over medium-low heat for and pour it over the nihari for a glossy finish. Serve topped with ginger matchsticks, chillies and coriander, with lemon squeezed over and naan or bread on the side.

    Add in this stepGhee or vegetable oil 1 tbspFresh ginger, cut into fine matchsticks (garnish) 10 gHot green chillies 1Fresh coriander (cilantro) 5 gLemon ½

    medium-low heat

Cook's tip

With a pressure cooker the long simmer in step 5 drops to 45 to 50 minutes on low once it reaches pressure. If the gravy is too thick add hot water; too thin, whisk in a little more flour slurry. Nihari tastes even better the next day, so it is worth making ahead and reheating.

Cooking it at camp

Cook it at home up to the end of step 5, cool it, and carry it in a sealed container in a cooler (below 5 °C); at the campsite reheat it on the burner and do steps 6 and 7. Starting from scratch outdoors needs almost three hours of fuel, so it is only realistic with a pressure cooker.